Background Literature
Although I certainly recognize the immense value of so many contemporary science education resources available to the interested reader and to students, I also believe the sheer spectrum of choices may cause even an adult, let alone a child, to be unable to attain the necessary learning focus. Consequently, I want to provide a very short list of useful resources that I would use (and have used) with children in order to build the initial background needed to understand the foundations of quantum vacuum technology at this level. I do so unapologetically, with no malice to other possible choices, but also out of my personal, positive experience with those I did include.
In order to provide a starting point for a focused conversation, in what follows I am assuming that your child or pupil has been exposed at least to a Kindergarten-introduction to magnetism, along the lines given in the book What Every Kindergartner Needs to Know, Hirsch, E. D., Editor, referenced in our resources section.
In that same section, I have enclosed a few hot links to a few educational sites of interest, which you are welcome to explore at your own leisure as they possibly apply to teaching these concepts to young children; none of those sites is assumed as a background in what follows. Once again, the amount of information available is overwhelming and I personally believe in creating a crossroads to focus the attention of children. You are certainly more than welcome to experiment with other curricula, of course.
Magnetism
Activities
One of the earliest activities you can carry out with your child
or with your pupils is to study magnetism by means of a permanent
magnet and a number of sample objects. These activities might involve
classifying those materials that appear attracted by a permanent
bar magnet as opposed to those that do not appear affected by it.
Some interesting questions might be whether all materials are attracted
by your magnet, whether magnetism goes through objects, and you
may want to even build a floating compass.
Fundamental
Interactions - Superforce - Unification
Magnetism is a manifestation of a fundamental interaction called
the electromagnetic force. Fundamental interactions are ultimately
involved in explaining everything we see around us in the universe
and they include: gravitation, the weak force, electromagnetism
(which we have just seen), and the strong force. All forces we experience
in nature can ultimately be explained on the basis of one or more
of these four. There has been a great effort to show that these
four forces are actually manifestations of one ``superforce.''
This is a trend
that started in the nineteenth century, when James Clerk Maxwell
succeeded in showing that electricity and magnetism are manifestations
of the same force, the electromagnetic force. More recently, scientists
have shown that the electromagnetic force and the weak force are
manifestations of the same interaction, referred to as the electro-weak
interaction. This effort to explain all fundamental interactions
as different manifestations of only one force is referred to as
unification.
Refining
conventional teaching about Neutral Objects
The interesting concept of dispersion forces, central to the research
and development activities at InterStellar Technologies Corporation,
challenges some of the facts children of all ages are usually exposed
to in their education. For instance, when pupils cover electricity,
they are told there are two types of charges, conventionally referred
to as positive and negative. An object that contains any charge
is referred to as charged ; if it contains neither type of charge,
an object is referred to as neutral. Pupils are told that objects
containing like charges (for instance both positive or both negative)
will repel each other; objects containing opposing charges (positive
and negative) will attract.
Then, pupils
are told that neutral objects will exert no net electric force on
one another. This is incorrect. In fact, neutral objects exert electromagnetic
forces on one another. For instance, two neutral, spherical atoms,
such as two helium atoms, will attract one another even though they
are not going to react chemically and form a molecule, as two hydrogen
atoms will, for instance. Similarly, a neutral, spherical atom in
front of a perfectly neutral metal plate will be attracted by it,
unlike what pupils are typically taught.
One of the most
stunning manifestations of these interactions between electrically
neutral objects was discovered theoretically by Casimir in the 1940s.
He obtained a prediction that two metal plates, parallel to one
another, would mutually attract even though they are perfectly neutral.
This is referred to as the Casimir effect.
Of course, this
concept presents an additional challenge for a pupil. One of the
most challenging concepts for young children is that of accepting
action at a distance between two objects that do not appear to touch
one another. Magnetism, for instance, is completely invisible. What
is ``touching'' the paper clip attracted by the bar magnet? The
parent/teacher will usually explain that, in order for magnetism
to work, there must be a magnet and a material sensitive to magnetism.
For instance, a bar magnet will attract a paper clip, but not a
piece of paper. Likewise, the paper clip will not be attracted by
a piece of copper (at least not magnetically).
In the case
of the Casimir effect, the challenge is to explain that there exists
a force between the two neutral objects apparently only caused by
their ``being there.'' Although this is certainly a challenging
notion for anyone, including adult readers, perhaps it is important
to expose the pupils to the fact that, although much of what happens
around us can be explained on the basis of what we clearly see,
sometimes we must focus on what we cannot see. The child is already
learning that magnetism, electricity, and gravitation, cannot be
seen in the common sense of the word. However, these forces are
real, and they can be connected to some properties the child can
be taught to expect by experience (magnetic materials, conductors,
etc.).
The Casimir
effect shows us that even objects that do not fit this characterization
can exert a force on one another, and this force is, fundamentally,
electromagnetic. What determines the exact behavior of this force
is the shape of the objects, their surface roughness, their optical
properties, and their temperature, among other things. This may
be left as a challenge for the future, but the pupil should not
move on simply believing that neutral objects ignore one another:
that is wrong as the experiments show and the theory of electromagnetism
explains.
Forces in
Empty Space
One further point of great importance to the parent/educator is
that one way to explain the Casimir force (one example of dispersion
forces) is to not look at (for instance) the two parallel plates,
but, instead, at the vacuum surrounding them. In other words, there
is a way to explain what happens by concentrating not on the objects
themselves, but on the vacuum around them. This is certainly a challenging
notion. However, it is important to prepare the pupil to the fact
that what happens in the universe may not only be determined by
objects, but also by completely empty space. Once the child can
stretch his or her mind to accepting the very existence of something
like the vacuum, the mind is ready to deal with a number of interesting
questions. For instance, what is left in space once everything else
has been removed (with a pump, for instance) ? What did early scientists
believe the vacuum is? Does the vacuum even exist?
By raising these
issues as appropriate by age, one is taking a little extra step:
from the fact that such a force as magnetism seems able to attract
through an invisible force, we are now accepting the fact that forces
may exist because somehow the nothingness of space is affected by
objects in it. It seems exotic, but the child will study that these
forces may be stronger than electromagnetism and gravity when two
surfaces are very close.
|